Ranking The GOP Defenses Of Melania Trump's Plagiarism Of Michelle Obama. | Gradient

Ranking the GOP defenses of Melania Trump’s plagiarism of Michelle Obama.

Michelle Obama Melania Trump

It was only Monday that Jarrett Hill noticed that sections of Melania Trump’s convention speech were lifted wholesale from Michelle Obama’s 2008 speech, but it feels like a whole new world. The air glitters. The sun radiates in strange waves. Clocks tick backward, and Team Trump is stuck trying to figure out a way to get around an incontrovertible truth: Melania Trump’s speech was plagiarized. Roll the tape!

In a normal year, with a normal candidate, the fix here would not be difficult. Scapegoat a nameless speechwriter, say said speechwriter has been fired, apologize for the mishap and the story is over by noon the next day. But this is not a normal year, and Trump is not a normal candidate so, the Trump train is dealing with this mess every way but the most direct one (it’s been established that nobody will be fired), and this story will have legs until Christmas.

Some of the ways the Trump campaign has found to get around all this have been more successful than others. Let’s take a look at them.

5. It wasn’t plagiarized.

This is the Trump campaign’s go-to method of dodging a scandal: Deny the plain facts of the matter.

“There’s no cribbing of Michelle Obama’s speech. These were common words and values. She cares about her family,” Trump campaign manager Paul Manafort said. “To think that she’d be cribbing Michelle Obama’s words is crazy.”

4. Look at how much of it wasn’t plagiarized!

In the past, Chris Christie has drawn a pretty hard line against plagiarism. (“I don’t think they were teaching plagiarism at Harvard Business School,” he told then-Wisconsin gubernatorial candidate Mary Burke upon learning she had copied some of her campaign materials. “I don’t think they were teaching you to cut and paste other peoples’ work and call it your own.”) These days, he’s feeling significantly more lenient, pointing out, hey, not all of the speech was plagiarized. When Matt Lauer asked Christie on television: “You’re a former prosecutor, could you make the case for plagiarism?” Christie responded: “Nah. Not when 93 percent of the speech is completely different than Michelle Obama’s speech.”

3. Things happen.

In an interview with MSNBC, Trump campaign co-chairman Sam Clovis gingerly engaged the issue that, yes, it did look like some parts of the speech were plagiarized but, hey, that’s D.C., baby! “I’m sure what happened is the person who was helping write this plucked something in there and probably an unfortunate oversight and certainly Melania didn’t have anything to do with it,” Clovis said, either unaware or unwilling to get into the fact that Mrs. Trump had claimed responsibility for writing most of it.

2. My Little Pony did it.

The less we know about how RNC Chief Strategist Sean Spicer can quote Twilight Sparkle, the better, but here we go! In a CNN interview with Wolf Blitzer in which Spicer appears to be staving off an impending heart attack, he rattles off several quotes from Melania Trump/Michelle Obama and then notes that similar sentiments were also expressed by John Legend, Kid Rock and, yes, a My Little Pony staple named Twilight Sparkle. So there.

1. This is Hillary Clinton’s fault.

In an entirely expected yet still astonishing to behold spectacle early Tuesday morning, Paul Manafort opened his mouth and used his words to express his belief that Melania Trump plagiarizing Michelle Obama was Hillary Clinton’s fault. “Once again, this is an example of when a woman threatens Hillary Clinton she seeks to demean her and take her down,” Manafort somehow said on CNN without his head exploding into flames.

As of this writing, the Clinton campaign hasn’t said anything at all about the accusations of plagiarism or, indeed, about Melania Trump in general.

If you enjoy ‘Reactions’, subscribe to our podcast In Case You Missed It.

New Pod Flow: Sounds Good With Branden Harvey “Jason Russell”


Jason is the cofounder of the iconic non-profit Invisible Children which was founded to increase awareness of the horrendous activities of the LRA in Central Africa. Jason was also the director of the iconic Kony 2012 film that took the world by storm. In this two-part interview Jason and Branden talk about what it means to create a movement, what Jason experienced during his breakdown and subsequent recovery, and Jason’s experience in the world of theater.

New Pod Flow: Animalators, “ Aharon Rabinowitz”


Aharon Rabinowitz is the head of marketing for Red Giant based in New York City. During our conversation, we discussed the importance of work life balance, his start as a production intern at Sesame Street and why artist’s feel personally offended when you reject their work.

New Pod Flow: In Case You Missed It, Episode 040


United gets their cheap on, fake news, and Trump hired who?

New Pod Flow: Scribble & Jam, “Artist Matthew Perryman Jones”


Welcome to Episode IV. This week, Dan spends some time with his favorite singer/songwriter, Matthew Perryman Jones. Matthew and Dan talk about panic attacks, growing up in Atlanta, the way music is informed by pain and suffering and the way music gives freedom.

If you have spent any time watching television in the last decade you have most likely heard one of Mattew’s songs on shows like Grey’s Anatomy, Pretty Little Liars, One Tree Hill and many others. His insightful writing and voice have drawn comparisons to Leonard Cohen and Jeff Buckley, and he is on the short list of songwriters who skillfully weave the deeply philosophical and the vivid utterly human without ever losing sight of either.

To get his new album Cold Answer, (which features the three songs from him you heard on this episode), visit MPJmusic.com.

Subscribe on iTunes.

New Pod Flow: Sounds Good With Branden Harvey “Next Steps After the Presidential Election”


Branden sits down with writer and speaker Tyler Huckabee days after Donald Trump was elected President of the United States to talk about empathy, justice, listening, and where we go from here.

New Pod Flow: In Case You Missed It, Episode 039


Special Election Edition, President Trump to legalized weed and everything in between.

This week we reflect on the election and discuss our strategies for staying sane.

New Pod Flow: Animalators, “Illo


Luca and Ilenia are the founders of Illo, a studio based in Turin, Italy.  During our conversation, we discussed their self-driving video bot named Algo, how Illo was formed and how they’ve crafted a unique office culture.

New Pod Flow: In Case You Missed It, Episode 038


This week we discuss Beyonce’s night at the CMAs, last minute election plans and how SNL might save us all.

Subscribe on iTunes and Stitcher.

New Pod Flow: It’s a Bird, It’s a Plane, It’s a Podcast: Doctor Strange


We appreciate everyone sticking with us through this long hiatus but are planning our return even as we speak, with a bunch of new goodies and an updated format. In the meantime, here’s a brief primer on Marvel’s Sorcerer Supreme, Doctor Strange — just so you can go into the movie knowing what you’re getting yourself into.